Dead or Dormant? How to Tell During the Winter Months

We've passed the peak of fall colors in Cincinnati this past week, and now the leaves are dropping. While we are busy clearing leaves off our cars and walkways, deciduous trees have entered a state of dormancy. Over the next couple of months, they will remain mostly unchanged as they conserve their energy for the spring.
During this period, it can be very difficult to tell if a tree in your yard is dead or dormant. A dead tree poses a safety risk, while a dormant tree will come back to life in the spring. Thankfully, simple techniques can help you tell whether a tree is still alive, even without leaves.

Why Some Trees Go Dormant in the Winter
Not all trees have the same yearly cycle. Some lose their leaves every year as sunlight levels drop and temperatures fall, while others keep their leaves year-round. In the Cincinnati area, we have a great variety of trees, so we are lucky to see them all at their unique stages throughout the entire year. These trees are generally split into two categories:
Deciduous Trees
These trees shed their leaves each autumn to conserve energy during the winter months. Come spring, buds will emerge, and the tree will grow its leaves back again. Common trees in this category include:
Maples
Ginkgo biloba
Birches
Willows
Most oak species

Evergreen Trees
These trees keep their foliage year-round rather than dropping everything at once. However, they do still gradually shed older needles or leaves as new growth replaces them. Common trees in this category include:
Spruces
Pines
Firs
Junipers
Southern magnolias

I noted "most oak species" under deciduous trees because some oaks, like white and pin oaks common in Cincinnati, show marcescence. This means they keep dead, brown leaves through winter, shedding them in spring. While they might look dead, these trees are healthy and will lose their old leaves as new growth appears.
So, How Do You Tell If a Tree is Dead or Dormant?
On the surface, it is nearly impossible to tell whether a deciduous tree is alive or dead in winter. Because of this, you will need to closely inspect your tree.
One way is to do the scratch test on a small twig of the tree. To do so:
Use your fingernail or a small knife (aim the knife away from yourself and watch your fingers!) to carefully scrape away the outer bark of the twig.
Dormant: This tissue underneath will be green and moist
Dead: The tissue underneath will be brown, dry, and brittle
It is a good idea to spot-check multiple parts of the tree, as a dormant tree can have dead sections while the rest is alive
Another easy way to check the tree is to do a bend test.
Gently bend a small twig or branch that is within reach.
Dormant: The branch will be flexible and bends without breaking easily
Dead: The branch will be stiff and snap easily

Branches that snap easily indicate the tree may be dead
Lastly, checking for buds, especially during the late winter, can be an easy way to tell if a tree is still alive.
Dormant: Buds look firm, plump, and healthy (buds can be green, brown, or red depending on the species) and stay attached
Dead: Buds are shriveled, hollow, or missing
Some other general visual indicators can also help you assess if your tree is dead or dying. Look for peeling or missing bark with dry wood underneath, mushrooms at the trunk's base, and a completely brittle, lifeless canopy as spring approaches.
What's Next?
If you are concerned about your tree during the winter months, it is always a good idea to reach out to a professional. Our tree health professionals and ISA Certified arborists check trees like this year-round and are experienced enough to tell by looking at the buds on the tree branches.
In fact, the dormant season is a great time to get ahead on pruning your trees, as structural defects are more visible since there is no thick leaf cover. Along with this, pests and diseases are also dormant, so there is no risk of infection through open wounds.


